Back to blog

eSIM vs Traditional SIM Cards: Which is Better for International Travel?

Mobile connectivity abroad presents international travelers with a vital choice between an eSIM card and a traditional physical SIM card. This decision matters more now as smartphone makers increasingly adopt eSIM technology that lets travelers stay connected while visiting different countries. The right choice can affect both convenience and costs during trips abroad.
Journey eSIM
Profile Picture

LAST UPDATED

SHARE
Profile Picture
Journey eSIM

LAST UPDATED

Mobile connectivity abroad presents international travelers with a vital choice between an eSIM card and a traditional physical SIM card. This decision matters more now as smartphone makers increasingly adopt eSIM technology that lets travelers stay connected while visiting different countries. The right choice can affect both convenience and costs during trips abroad.

 

This piece dives into the main differences between eSIMs and traditional SIM cards for travelers. You'll learn about device compatibility with eSIMs, benefits of travel eSIMs in destinations like Japan, the USA, and Europe. The discussion includes unlimited data eSIM options and helps you pick the best solution based on your needs and travel preferences.

 

What are eSIMs and How Do They Work?

 

 

An embedded SIM (eSIM) is a digital SIM card built right into a device's motherboard that eliminates the need for a physical card 1. This innovative technology revolutionizes the way users connect to mobile networks, especially when you have international travel plans.

 

The eSIM's functionality is simple and straightforward. Users get a unique QR code by email after purchase. Scanning this code activates the eSIM and creates smooth connectivity 2. One of the most important advantages lets a single device support all but one of these eSIMs at once. This makes it easy for travelers to manage multiple service providers 2.

 

Modern devices come ready for eSIM technology. Most smartphones released in the last five years include eSIM capability 3. The activation process needs:

 

  • A stable internet connection
  • A QR code from the service provider
  • Device settings configuration
  • Data roaming activation

 

The technology works by storing carrier profiles digitally on an eUICC chip that can be reprogrammed with new SIM information as needed 4. Each eSIM's unique factory-programmed eSIM ID (EID) helps link the device with carrier subscriptions 4. This digital nature makes it valuable to international travelers because they don't need to visit physical stores or wait for SIM card deliveries 5.

 

 

Benefits of eSIMs for International Travel

 

 

Travel eSIMs have transformed how we stay connected internationally and give travelers unmatched convenience and flexibility. Travelers can now enjoy uninterrupted connectivity in multiple destinations without dealing with physical SIM cards 6.

 

Key Advantages for International Travelers:

 

  • QR code scanning activates service right when you arrive 7
  • You can store and switch between different carrier profiles based on your location 7
  • Better security through encryption and biometric authentication 8
  • Local network access cuts down roaming charges by a lot 6
  • Less plastic waste and lower CO2 emissions help the environment 9

 

Travel eSIMs shine when it comes to regional coverage. Users stay connected in multiple countries without switching plans 7. This technology gives families and business travelers great data-sharing options and steady local rates 10.

 

The security benefits of eSIM technology stand out clearly. These chips are built right into devices and can't be removed or tampered with, which cuts down the risk of data breaches 6. Device-to-carrier server communications stay encrypted to ensure safe profile setup and management 8.

 

Smart travelers who watch their budgets find eSIMs are economical solutions, especially when trips last more than a week 11. You won't need physical SIM cards anymore, plus you can keep your home number while using local data 7.

 

 

Advantages of Traditional SIM Cards

 

 

Traditional SIM cards are the life-blood of mobile connectivity, and they connect over 8 billion devices to cellular networks worldwide 12. These cards have stayed popular because they work with every device and rely on a 20-year old infrastructure. Traditional SIM card vendors earn over AUD 10.01 billion in revenue 12.

 

Key Benefits of Traditional SIM Cards:

 

  • Better local network coverage and faster data speeds in destination countries 13
  • Cheaper than international roaming rates 14
  • Fixed costs with predefined data plans 13
  • Better physical security since you can remove them 15
  • Easy to find at phone stores, electronics shops, and supermarkets 14

 

Traditional SIM cards shine when it comes to smooth local connectivity. Travelers can access local networks and get reliable coverage even in remote areas 13. These physical cards give users a security advantage because they can remove or destroy the SIM whenever needed 15.

 

Local SIM cards are the most cost-effective option for travelers who stay in one place. Users get data, talk, and text bundles that match local market needs 13. This setup helps avoid roaming fees completely and provides a local number. A local number is a great way to get in touch with fellow travelers or receive important messages 13.

 

 

Choosing Between eSIM and Traditional SIM for Your Trip

 

 

You need to weigh several practical factors when choosing between an eSIM and traditional SIM card. Your travel duration and specific connection needs will guide this decision.

 

Traditional roaming packages like Vodafone's AUD 7.70/day plan are more economical for trips under a week 11. The math changes substantially when you travel longer than seven days - a week of roaming costs AUD 53.88, which equals a month-long eSIM plan 11.

 

Key Decision Factors to Think About:

 

  • Device Compatibility: Check if your device supports eSIM before you decide 16
  • Trip Duration: eSIMs work out cheaper for longer trips 11
  • Network Coverage: Traditional SIMs give you better local coverage 17
  • Calling Requirements: WiFi calling helps you keep your home number working 18

 

eSIMs let you set everything up before your trip and get online as soon as you land 17. Traditional SIM cards might be a better fit if you want to switch carriers easily or need a card that works with any device 16.

 

Your travel habits and comfort with technology will shape your final choice. eSIMs are great for convenience and digital management, while traditional SIM cards stand out for their wide compatibility and reliable local connections 11.

 

Conclusion

 

 

Travelers today have clear benefits when choosing between eSIM and traditional SIM options. Each option meets different priorities. eSIMs provide digital convenience and flexibility with multiple carriers. Traditional SIM cards deliver reliable local coverage and work with all devices. The length of your stay is a vital factor to consider. Longer trips work better with eSIMs because they are economical and easier to manage. Other key factors include security, network coverage, and calling needs.

 

You can get uninterrupted connectivity abroad with good planning, whatever option you pick. Journey eSIM proves to be a dependable choice for travelers who want easy digital connectivity without dealing with physical cards. The future points to more devices and carriers adopting eSIM technology. Traditional SIM cards will still matter for certain trips and older devices. Travelers can make better choices by understanding both technologies' strengths and evaluating their specific needs.

 

 

FAQs

 

 

  1. What are the limitations of using an eSIM?
    The primary limitation of eSIMs is that they are only supported by a select number of high-end smartphones, which may not be affordable for everyone. This restricts the availability of eSIMs to those who can invest in these premium devices.

  2. Which is more advantageous for general use, an eSIM or a traditional SIM card?  While it's difficult to definitively state which is superior, eSIMs offer greater versatility, enhanced security, and are more environmentally friendly. They are particularly beneficial for frequent travelers or those who often switch carriers or phones.

  3. Is an eSIM suitable for international travel?
    Yes, eSIMs function similarly to traditional SIM cards when it comes to international roaming. They allow for digital management of your plan, making it easier to add data or make changes as needed while abroad.

  4. Do eSIMs provide better network coverage compared to traditional SIM cards?
    eSIMs do not inherently provide better signal strength than traditional SIM cards. Any differences in coverage are likely due to external factors rather than the type of SIM technology used.

  5. What are the key differences between eSIMs and physical SIM cards?

    • Compatibility: eSIMs are compatible with newer devices and their support is expanding, whereas physical SIMs are universally compatible with a wide range of devices and networks.
    • Flexibility: eSIMs can store multiple profiles for quick network changes, while physical SIMs can be easily swapped among different devices.
    • Security: eSIMs are embedded and harder to clone, offering enhanced security and traceability. Physical SIMs can be removed and are less secure if lost or stolen.
    • Convenience for Travelers: eSIMs provide instant access to local data plans abroad without needing to visit a physical store, whereas physical SIMs require a physical swap and dealing with different providers for international plans.

 

 

References

 

 

[1] - https://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/esim-explainer/
[2] - https://travelsim.com/a-complete-guide-to-esims-how-they-work-benefits-2023/
[3] - https://www.wired.com/story/how-to-use-buy-esim-international-travel-trips/
[4] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ESIM
[5] - https://simbud.com/how-to-use-esims-for-travel/
[6] - https://www.globalyo.com/advantages-of-using-esim-for-travel/
[7] - https://www.getnomad.app/blog/should-i-get-a-travel-esim-for-my-trip
[8] - https://www.cm-alliance.com/cybersecurity-blog/security-benefits-of-esims-over-sim-cards-for-international-travel
[9] - https://boost.com.au/pages/esim
[10] - https://journeywithus.co/blogs/news/the-pros-and-cons-of-international-sim-cards-vs-international-roaming-plans?srsltid=AfmBOop2wbkZRhizrdoFATt6HAkiD0kSjz2MeuZkOmTP0F2kMDwqp6Dm
[11] - https://www.pointhacks.com.au/traveling-with-esims/
[12] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SIM_card
[13] - https://www.europesimcard.com.au/should-i-get-a-new-sim-card-when-traveling-abroad/
[14] - https://www.scti.com.au/travel-advice/your-guide-to-international-sim-cards
[15] - https://ar-pay.com/blog/en/esim-card/esim-vs-traditional-sim-cards/?srsltid=AfmBOoqiqQ9rvSkxv0K0cfETuH0Am2c3LRG1zAs1WI5CPT-kZW69Febu
[16] - https://simsdirect.com.au/blogs/travel/esim-vs-sim-a-comprehensive-comparison-for-travelers?srsltid=AfmBOopkp7kYGDy5CehzdwqThEB5bzYEscwQw2nMIf4tbTklK2dj04Fv
[17] - https://www.globalyo.com/esim-vs-physical-sim-which-is-the-best-option-for-travelers/
[18] - https://www.tripadvisor.com.au/ShowTopic-g1-i12530-k14654887-E_SIM_versus_SIM-Travel_Gadgets_and_Gear.html